Are Manual Cars Inherently More Dangerous Than Modern Automatic Cars?

Some experts believe that manual vehicles are safer because they require the driver to pay more attention to their surroundings and to the vehicle itself. Others think that automatic cars are safer because they are more responsive in certain situations, and they can be less challenging to control. Ultimately, it is up to the individual driver to decide which type of car is best for them.

Pros Of Driving A Manual Vehicle

There are arguments for driving a manual vehicle. Some of the more common are listed below:

• It’s an adventure: In a manual vehicle, you are in control, shifting when you want. Imagine driving on the Autobahn in a manual car.
• You can drive any car: If you know how to operate a manual, you can borrow any vehicle without worrying about an automatic transmission. In European countries, manual transmissions are more common (think sports cars), and you will have no problem renting one while on vacation.

• It is less expensive: Manual vehicles can be up to $1,000 cheaper to purchase. Add to that that they are easier on gas mileage, and you might save quite a bit.
• A valuable skill set: You can use your new skills on other vehicles. Using both feet to operate a manual transmission is a skill set that takes time to learn. However, once you do, you can use it on other vehicles such as an ATV or a motorcycle. However, motorcycle riders must learn their own set of safety skills, so as to avoid accidents that often lead to personal injury claims.
• Maintenance is easier: Manual vehicles are much easier to maintain. The only repair focus might be the clutch, and it takes time to need that. In addition, the need for gear or engine oil changes is less.
• Gas savings: Without having a hydraulic pump and a torque converter, manual vehicles use less gas. It is possible to use 15 percent less gas by driving a manual car.
• Improve acceleration: Tests show that a manual transmission has better acceleration than an automatic. This is critical with a small engine.

Cons Of Driving A Manual Vehicle

Although manual vehicles are fun and economical to drive, there are a few downsides you should consider:

• Left leg pain: Using the clutch repeatedly affects the muscles and ligaments in your left leg. Over time, this can become a problem.
• Hills are not easy: A manually controlled vehicle can have trouble starting on a hill. This can be dangerous if there is heavy traffic behind you.
• Learning to drive a clutch is not easy: There is a big learning curve when first driving a manual car. It takes time to get used to driving with a clutch.
• Experience is needed: Manual vehicles require more skill than automatic.

Pros Of Driving A Vehicle With Automatic Transmission

Just as with manual vehicles, automatics have their own set of pros and cons. Let’s look at the pros first:

• Changing gears: You don’t have to worry about shifting gears while driving.
• More power: Automatic transmissions can handle much more power, often found in high-performance cars.
• Automatics are better in heavy traffic: They’re easier to use in stop-and-go traffic.
• Saving your left foot and leg: You don’t have to use your left foot to operate the clutch pedal, avoiding physical problems such as leg and knee pain.

HeadingCons Of Driving An Automatic Vehicle

There are problems with an automatic transmission. Some of the most common are:

• Control might be less: You may not have as much control over the car.
• Repairs cost more: Automatic transmissions can be less durable than manuals, and repairs can be expensive.
• Fuel efficiency is not as good: They can be less fuel-efficient than manuals in some cases.
• Performance may be affected: Automatics may not perform as well as manuals in off-road or towing situations.

Consumer Reports tested the fuel efficiency of both manual and automatic vehicles. Several American cars were tested, and it was determined that manual transmissions could save the driver between two to five mpg.

Which Vehicle Type Is Safer?

Overall, the intimate relationship between a car and driver found with manual vehicles may make them inherently safer since it forces the driver to focus. However, there’s also a greater chance that a manual transmission car will stall, which can cause an accident if it happens at the wrong time. In motor vehicle injury cases, this can especially be a fault used against the manual driver. Either way, both types of transmissions have their pros and cons when it comes to safety.

While there are pros and cons to consider with each type of transmission, there’s no definitive answer as to which is better. It ultimately comes down to personal preference. If you’re not comfortable driving a manual car, then an automatic may be the best choice for you. On the other hand, if you enjoy the challenge and control of a manual car, then that may be the better option. Whichever type of transmission you choose, be sure to practice safe driving habits on the road.