Is $1,800 a Fair Price for Motor Mount and Dampener Replacement on a 1999 Toyota Avalon?

QuestionsCategory: Ask An ExpertIs $1,800 a Fair Price for Motor Mount and Dampener Replacement on a 1999 Toyota Avalon?
Olivia Thompson asked 3 months ago
Hi! I'm in a bit of a situation with my 1999 Toyota Avalon. Recently, my car's motor has been shaking violently, and upon inspection, I was advised that all motor mounts and the dampener need replacing. The quote I received was $1,800, and I'm unsure if this is a reasonable price. Given the age of my car and my current financial situation, this amount seems quite high. I'm seeking advice on whether this quote is fair and what my best options might be.
1 Answers
Zack Norman Staff answered 3 months ago
Hi there, Olivia! It's great that you're seeking a second opinion on this. Motor mount replacement costs can vary widely based on the car's model, the extent of the damage, and the labor rates of the shop. Here's a breakdown for your 1999 Toyota Avalon:
  1. Cost of Parts: Motor mounts and a dampener for your model typically range between $100 to $150. Prices can vary based on quality and brand.
  2. Labor Costs: The labor for this job can be intensive, especially if multiple mounts need replacement. For a vehicle like yours, labor costs can range from $250 to $400 in a small independent shop. However, these rates can be higher in dealerships or specialized repair shops.
  3. DIY Considerations: If you're mechanically inclined, some mounts are manageable to replace yourself, potentially saving on labor costs. However, the rear mount, which might require removing the axle, can be challenging. It's essential to balance the potential savings against the risks of incomplete or incorrect installation.
  4. Comparing Quotes: Your quote of $1,800 does seem on the higher end, especially considering the age and value of your car. It's advisable to get quotes from a few different repair shops for comparison. This can provide a clearer picture of the fair market price in your area.
  5. Partial Replacement Option: Some mechanics suggest that often only the front mount needs replacement. You might consider replacing only the most problematic mounts now and addressing others later if needed.
  6. Alternative Solutions: Purchasing the mounts yourself and finding a reputable local mechanic who agrees to install parts you provide could be a cost-saving alternative. Some local shops are open to this arrangement.
In conclusion, while $1,800 might be a bit steep for your car's age and the nature of the repair, it's essential to balance cost-saving measures against the quality and safety of the repair. We recommend getting a few more quotes and considering a partial or DIY approach if feasible. Zack - Motor Verso Mechanics Team